Year
How to use the database
HANDS OFF CAIN’S 2015 REPORT
The worldwide situation (as of 30 June 2016)
EXECUTIONS IN 2014
EXECUTIONS IN 2015 (as of 30 June)
The most important facts of 2015 (and the first six months of 2016)
ADDRESS of Pope Francis
THE SMILING FACE OF THE MULLAHS
Reportage by Sergio D'Elia
ANALYSIS OF THE 2015 REPORT DATA AND OBJECTIVES OF HANDS OFF CAIN
Reportage by Marco Perduca
"THE ABOLITIONIST OF THE YEAR 2015” AWARD
Protocol of understanding between NTC and CNF
Dossier on death penalty and homosexuality
Final declaration of the Cairo workshop
Goals
Achievements
GENERAL MOTION OF THE FIFTH CONGRESS OF HOC
RESOLUTION OF THE KIGALI CONFERENCE
U.N. RESOLUTION 2014

U.N. RESOLUTION 2012
U.N. RESOLUTION 2010

REPORT ON THE 2ND ANNUAL EU FORUM ON THE DEATH PENALTY IN ZAMBIA

Videos

DECLARATION OF LIBREVILLE

Publications
Hands Off Cain Headquarters
U.N. RESOLUTION 2008

U.N. RESOLUTION 2007

Appeal To The United Nations
Board of Directors

LETHAL TRADE DOSSIER
2014 FREETOWN CONFERENCE Final Declaration
THE COTONOU DECLARATION 2014
DOSSIER IRAQ 2003

DOSSIER ON MORATORIUM
DOSSIER IRAQ 2012

DOSSIER USA 2011

NOBEL LAUREATES APPEAL
Bulletin Board
Sign up
Join appeal
Newsletter
Our Publications

LESOTHO: DEATH PENALTY FOR HIV RAPISTS UNCONSTITUTIONAL, TOP COURT RULES

November 11, 2022: A decision by the constitutional division of Lesotho’s High Court has found controversial provisions in that country’s sexual offences law, unconstitutional.
In particular, the court held that stipulating the death penalty for a convicted rapist, held to have known he was HIV positive at the time of the crime, infringed the constitutional right to freedom from discrimination and to a right to equality before the law.
Just over 20 years ago, Lesotho’s then Minister of Justice, Law & Constitutional Affairs, Refiloe Masemene, introduced a new Bill on sexual offences to Parliament. Among other proposals, accepted by MPs and brought into law, was this: that the penalty for a convicted rapist, aware at the time of the crime that he was HIV positive, was the death sentence.
Last year, a magistrate presiding in a rape case with facts like these, forwarded the case to the High Court for sentencing as she did not have the jurisdiction to impose the death penalty. The High Court, in turn, believing that the case presented serious constitutional issues, asked for further input from relevant sectors of civil society as friends of the court, particularly the Lesotho Network of People Living with HIV and AIDS (LENEPWA).
The case was argued in May 2021, and judgment was given last week. Delivering the court’s unanimous decision in the matter, Judge Molefi Makara explained the delay. He said that his laptop had become infected by a ‘ransom virus’ and that it had ‘graphically distorted the draft judgment in my over five-years-old laptop.’ The relevant information technology unit had been unable to replace the machine and this had added to the delay.
On the subject of the constitutionality of the death penalty provisions where a rape accused knew they were HIV positive, counsel claimed these provisions breached a slew of guaranteed rights, among them the right to life, to freedom from inhuman treatment, fair trial rights, the right to respect for private life, and the rights to equality before the law as well as to the equal protection of the law.
In his decision, Makara found that the magistrate should first have decided whether there were extenuating circumstances in relation to the accused. Only after making those decisions, would she have been able to decide on a proper punishment. Only if she had found that he did, indeed, merit the death penalty, would she have needed to send the case to the High Court for sentencing.
He stressed that the magistrate had to consider the appropriate penalty for herself, since the legislature was not empowered to ‘deprive the judiciary’ of its inherent judicial powers including sentencing.
Dealing with the question of whether the rights to equality before the law and to the equal protection of the law had been breached by the section that mandated the death penalty for a convicted rapist who knew he was HIV positive at the time of the crime, Makara said the idea of equal protection of the law was ancient in origin, and had been prevalent ‘from the classical era and across the successive phases of civilisations. He quoted from the Bible to show that this was an idea enshrined there, and then moved to international legal instruments that embodied this principle in more modern times.
He pointed to the problem that the death penalty was not prescribed for other sexually transmittable diseases ‘that are relatively and potentially life-threatening analogous to HIV’.
‘Here reference could be made to syphilis, human papilloma (HPV) and hepatitis, mainly due to their secondary sequelae.’
The current medical reality in relation to treatment of HIV had to be contrasted with earlier views when there were ‘no medical interventions’ for HIV. This lay behind the decision of Parliament to prescribe the death penalty, as there was a predominant perception that such a crime ‘effectively amounted to the sentencing of the victim to death.’
Parliament reacted from a state of panic and passed the legislation to ‘save human lives’. Since then, however, medical advancements had largely removed that rationale for prescribing the death penalty in such cases.
Makara said it made ‘constitutional sense’ in the case of someone convicted of a sexual offence to remove the veil of the accused’s right to privacy. By mandating a compulsory HIV test for the accused, Parliament had the legitimate intention to protect ‘the victim of the offence, the family and the public’.
He added: ‘Incidentally, this would benefit others who could in future interact intimately with the victim. It would further conscientise the victim to timeously receive treatment and to (tread) carefully when dealing with other people.’
The court concluded that the law prescribing the death penalty was unconstitutional in violating the right to equality before the law and equal protection of the law. It also found that the right to freedom from inhuman treatment was infringed by the law.
However, the court declined to find that the death penalty itself was unconstitutional in Lesotho.
What should happen about the sentence to be passed in the case of the man at the centre of the matter, who was convicted of rape? The Constitutional Court said that the issue was to be sent back to the trial court for the magistrate to determine the appropriate sentence in the light of the new findings, and that the Director of Public Prosecutions should intervene to ensure the matter was dealt with speedily.
The court thanked, among others an expert witness from the Desmond Tutu HIV Centre of the University of Cape Town, along with the Kenya Legal and Ethical Issues Network in helping sponsor counsel for the friends of the court. The Southern African Litigation Centre (SALC) was also thanked for its help in the matter. Commenting after the decision was delivered, SALC quoted the executive director of LENEPWHA, Maketekete Thotolo, who said the judgment acknowledged that the ‘over-broad use of criminal laws and sanctions solely based on HIV status is unjust and not justified by a scientific and human-rights based approach’. (Source: Legalbrief, 02/11/2022)

USA - Alabama. Jimmy Spencer sentenced to death
KENYA: MAN SENTENCED TO DEATH FOR STEALING FROM A BODA BODA RIDER
IRAN - Execution of two prisoners in Torbat Jam prison on November 14
IRAN - Dawood Bahrami executed in Hamadan on November 14
USA - Gallup poll: 55% Support Death Penalty, 42% against, 3% abstentions.
INDIA: SUPREME COURT ACQUITS 3 MEN ON DEATH ROW FOR DELHI TEEN’S RAPE-MURDER
IRAN - Sultan Seifi executed in Qom on November 13
IRAN - 3 men executed in Zahedan on November 13
DEATH PENALTY: UN SUPPORT TO A MORATORIUM GROWS TO 126 MEMBER STATES
IRAN - Three Men Executed in Shiraz on November 12
SOMALIA: MILITARY COURT EXECUTES BY FIRING SQUAD AL-SHABAAB OPERATIVE IN GALKAYO
IRAN - More than 54 minors under the age of 18 killed in the nationwide uprising
SOMALIA: TEN AL-SHABAAB CONVICTS EXECUTED WITHIN TWO WEEKS
TUNISIA: LAUNCH OF A NETWORK OF LAWYERS AGAINST THE DEATH PENALTY
INDIA: SUPREME COURT COMMUTES DEATH PENALTY OF RAPE, MURDER CONVICT WHO SPENT 10-YRS SOLITARY CONFINEMENT IN JAIL
ECPM: 8TH WORLD CONGRESS AGAINST THE DEATH PENALTY IN BERLIN FROM 15 TO 18 NOVEMBER 2022
USA - Texas. Taylor Parker sentenced to death
SOMALIA: AL-SHABAAB HITMEN EXECUTED A DAY AFTER A DEADLY CAR BOMBINGS
MALAYSIA: 24 YEAR-OLD SENTENCED TO DEATH FOR MURDER OF DENTAL TECHNOLOGIST
USA - Texas. Tracy Beatty executed on November 9
IRAN - Iranian Protester Handed Death Sentence
IRAN - Iran Votes to Execute Protesters
IRAN - Shoaib Askani and Eshagh Askani executed in Zahedan on November 8
IRAN - Rashed Baloch and Ishaq Ishaq executed in Zahedan on November 8
IRAN - Five prisoners executed in Arak prison
EGYPT: GRAND MUFTI UPHOLDS DEATH SENTENCE FOR SALMA BAHGAT'S KILLER
SOMALIA: TWO ISIS MILITANTS EXECUTED IN MOGADISHU
GHANA: PRESIDENT AKUFO-ADDO WANTS DEATH PENALTY ABOLISHED
SINGAPORE: INDIAN-ORIGIN MAN ACQUITTED AFTER GETTING DEATH PENALTY VIA ZOOM
IRAN - Nematollah Barahouyi and Amanollah Alizehi executed in Zahedan on November 6

[<< Prec] 1 2 3 4 [Succ >>]
2024
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2023
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2022
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2021
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2020
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
 
2019
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2018
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2017
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2016
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2015
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2014
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
 
2013
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2012
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2011
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2010
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2009
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2008
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
 
2007
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2006
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2005
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
  2004
january
february
march
april
may
june
july
august
september
october
november
december
 
IRAN - Wife of Djalali pleads for EU action
  IRAN - Hands off Cain Year End Report: At least 284 executions in 2020  
  IRAN: HANDS OFF CAIN, THE HANGING OF THE PROTESTER MOSTAFA SALEHI IS A SHAME FOR THE SO-CALLED DEMOCRATIC WORLD   
  USA: ‘BLACK LIVES MATTER’, BUT IS IT ONLY RACISM?  
  IRAN. HANDS OFF CAIN, REDUCTION OF DRUG EXECUTIONS BUT NUMBERS REMAIN WORRISOME  
  HUMAN RIGHTS: DEMONSTRATION OF THE RADICAL PARTY BEFORE IRANIAN EMBASSY 14 FEBRUARY  
news
-
latest actions
-
data base
-
actions
-
who we are
-
registered users
-
credits